society Practical Magic

Dropping out of an apprenticeship only hurts your career if you are from a poor family.

March 31, 2026

Original Paper

Stratified scars: social inequality in the labour market consequences of apprenticeship dropout

Kerstin Ostermann, Alexander Patzina, Katy Morris

SocArXiv · zy6h5_v3

The Takeaway

Using a 'scarring' model, the study found that the financial penalty for quitting a professional track is entirely concentrated among disadvantaged individuals. Students from wealthy backgrounds have social buffers that allow them to quit without the 'scar' ever showing up in their future wages.

From the abstract

While the association between apprenticeship dropout and negative labour market consequences is well documented, the causal link and social stratification in this effect are less clear. Using georeferenced German administrative data and a conditional instrumental variable approach that exploits distance between place of residence and large firms, we find negative financial consequences but show that the dropout penalty is entirely concentrated among individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds. We