economics Paradigm Challenge

The stock market frequently goes up immediately after a major bank fails.

March 31, 2026

Original Paper

The Relief Rally: A Ninety-Year Event Study of Positive,Market Reactions to U.S. Bank Failures

Chris Manfre

SSRN · 6495000

The Takeaway

Analyzing 90 years of data, the paper identifies a 'relief rally' phenomenon where the Dow Jones and S&P 500 often show positive abnormal returns following a bank failure. This happens because the failure removes market uncertainty and triggers expectations of government intervention.

From the abstract

This paper examines equity market reactions to U.S. bank failures from 1934 to 2024, analyzing the Dow Jones Industrial Average and S&P 500 using event study methodologies. Drawing on foundational theories from Diamond-Dybvig (bank runs), Mishkin (financial instability), and behavioral finance insights, including Shiller's feedback loops, we explore direct effects and contagion risks. Our long-term analysis reveals that, historically, periods surrounding bank failure announcements show coun