economics Paradigm Challenge

Big oil companies are dumping their old wells onto tiny firms just to dodge billions in cleanup costs.

March 18, 2026

Original Paper

Cutting Costs or Cutting Corners: Asset Reallocation in Oil and Gas Production

Sarah Armitage, Judson Boomhower, Catherine Hausman

SSRN · 6425013

The Takeaway

While we assume drillers are responsible for cleaning up their wells, a massive secondary market exists to transfer high-liability 'dying' wells to 'judgment-proof' firms. When the well finally stops producing, the new owner simply goes bankrupt, leaving the multi-billion dollar cleanup bill to the public.

From the abstract

Reallocation of assets across firms can lead to efficiency gains, but it can also lead to distortions via rent-seeking. We examine the link between asset reallocation and rent-seeking enabled by differences in the expected cost of environmental liabilities. Focusing on the US oil and gas industry, we develop a conceptual framework that incorporates both firm specialization in well types and the judgment-proof problem, by which undercapitalized firms can avoid environmental liabilities. We then b